Hold onto your web-shooters, folks—Sadie Sink has officially joined Spider-Man 4, and the internet has immediately gone into full meltdown mode. The Stranger Things star’s casting has sparked a tidal wave of speculation, theories, and wild guesses about who she’s playing. And, of course, Marvel is keeping their usual level of secrecy, which is somewhere between “Fort Knox” and “Area 51.”
So, what do we actually know? And more importantly, what insane fan theories are floating around? Let’s dive into the madness.
The Official Details (Which Are Barely Details at All)
Marvel Studios has confirmed that Sadie Sink will be in Spider-Man 4, set for release on July 31, 2026. That’s it. That’s the big announcement. No character name, no hints, just “Hey, she’s in it. Figure it out yourselves.”
Naturally, fans have taken this as an invitation to turn Twitter (sorry, X) into a full-blown detective agency. And the leading theories?
Theory #1: Sadie Sink is Jean Grey (…In a Spider-Man Movie?)
The internet’s favorite theory is that Sink will play Jean Grey, the legendary telepathic mutant from the X-Men. Because, obviously, what every Spider-Man movie needs is another franchise crashing into it.
Sink herself responded to these rumors in an interview, saying:
This is news to me. I have nothing to say about this. The rumors are really cool, though. It’s an awesome rumor. I know the character. It’s a great character, so that was cool to read.
Translation: Either she’s genuinely clueless, or she’s been trained in the art of Marvel’s “I can’t confirm or deny” script.
Theory #2: Gwen Stacy, Because Redheads Have to Play Redheads
The second most popular theory is that Sink is taking on the role of Gwen Stacy, aka Peter Parker’s tragic love interest. In most versions of the comics, Gwen’s story doesn’t end well (unless you count the Spider-Gwen multiverse variant, in which case, she’s a total badass).
Marvel fans have been screaming for a live-action Spider-Gwen, and since Sink has the right look, the theory practically writes itself. If true, this could mean a multiversal crossover, another tragic love story, or maybe just another chance for Tom Holland to cry on-screen.
Theory #3: MJ 2.0 – A New Mary Jane Watson?
Since Zendaya’s MJ doesn’t technically go by “Mary Jane Watson,” some fans think Sink might be playing a new version of Spidey’s classic love interest. This would be a bold move, considering No Way Home left Peter heartbroken and forgotten by the world. Could this be Marvel’s way of rebooting the love story?
Or are we about to witness a love triangle messier than Peter Parker’s life already is?
Theory #4: A Brand-New Character No One Saw Coming
This is Marvel, after all. They love throwing curveballs. Maybe Sink isn’t playing any established comic book character at all. Maybe she’s someone completely original, a new villain, a new hero, or just some random person who has an unfortunate encounter with Spider-Man.
After all, Marvel has a habit of misleading fans. Remember when we all thought WandaVision was going to introduce the X-Men? Or when people believed Mephisto was lurking around every corner? Yeah. We should probably take all these theories with a grain of salt.
Tom Holland’s Spidey Saga Continues
While we obsess over Sink’s character, let’s not forget that Spider-Man 4 is continuing the story of Peter Parker post-No Way Home. With the world forgetting who he is and Peter essentially starting from scratch, we’re getting a new chapter of his journey.
More Read
Will he team up with Daredevil? Will he be hunted down by some terrifying new villain? Will he finally get a moment to just sit down and breathe? Probably not.
But one thing’s for sure: with Sadie Sink in the mix, the excitement levels for this film just skyrocketed.
Final Thoughts: Marvel, Just Tell Us Already
Marvel’s secrecy game is strong, but it’s only making fans more obsessed. Whether Sink is playing Jean Grey, Gwen Stacy, Mary Jane, or a completely new character, her involvement is enough to send hype levels through the roof.
Now, all we can do is wait. And theorize. And argue on the internet. Because what’s a Marvel casting announcement without a little chaos?
